Home ›News ›Chile’s Supreme Court questions proposed betting website blocking rules

Continuing coverage · Chile · Website blocking

Chile’s Supreme Court questions proposed betting website blocking rules

Chile’s Supreme Court has questioned plans to strengthen website blocking through the Code of Civil Procedure. Existing action against betting domains shows why the debate concerns the design and execution of enforcement, alongside a separate argument over market regulation.

Contents
Illustrative architectural scene inspired by Santiago's court buildings. A fictional interpretation, not an exact documentary photograph of the Supreme Court, a hearing, a judgment or a newly enacted blocking law.
Illustrative editorial image.

Chile’s Supreme Court has told lawmakers to reconsider a bill intended to strengthen enforcement of orders blocking online platforms. Its opinion, sent to the Senate on 12 November and publicised by the judiciary on 18 November, questions whether the proposed provisions add useful powers and whether the general civil procedure code is the right place for them.

The report concerns Bill 18.699-07. It is legislative advice on a draft, with the continuing execution of existing court orders and the separate debate over an online betting framework forming the wider context.

What the Supreme Court was asked to assess

The proposal would add Articles 238 bis, 238 ter and 238 quáter to the Code of Civil Procedure. Its purpose includes addressing new domains, subdomains and mirror sites used to continue access after a blocking order.

The report, signed by Supreme Court president Gloria Chevesich Ruiz following the full court’s 9 November review, describes requirements covering the addresses to be blocked, responsible parties, deadlines and evidence of compliance.

The draft also contains safeguards. As the court explains it, extending an order to new addresses would require technical evidence connecting them to the previously blocked platform, alongside protection for lawful internet services. The proposed measures would have to be suitable and proportionate.

These details matter because identifying a replacement address and proving its relationship to a targeted service are part of implementing an order accurately.

Why the court questioned the proposed route

The court’s criticism has two parts. Read broadly as general website-blocking provisions, the proposed additions appear to duplicate enforcement powers already available to judges under the existing code.

If the rules were narrowed to the online betting problem that motivated the proposal, the court saw a different difficulty: highly specific sector rules would sit awkwardly within a body of provisions intended to apply generally across proceedings.

The report therefore points lawmakers towards reconsidering the legislative approach, including the General Telecommunications Law or the legislation governing casinos and gambling supervision.

The court also suggests the obstacle may lie in factors beyond insufficient judicial enforcement powers. In our assessment, that puts a practical burden on the case for reform: identify the part of the process that fails and show how the proposed rule would improve it.

Chile already has a process for fresh domains

The background is an active enforcement system. On 1 September 2026, telecommunications authority Subtel instructed the notified internet providers to block a list of 42 URLs validated by the Superintendencia de Casinos de Juego, or SCJ. The notice specified DNS blocking within 48 hours of notification.

On 21 September, Subtel announced a further list of 37 domains for blocking under the court-established procedure. Its explanation expressly addressed new domains, subdomains and mirrors.

The described process combines reporting addresses, SCJ validation, Subtel notification and implementation by the relevant providers. Providers must demonstrate compliance to the Santiago Court of Appeals and send a copy to Subtel. The procedure also provides for correcting identification errors or effects on lawful services.

These are counts of addresses in enforcement notices. They provide evidence of continuing administrative work, without establishing the number of separate operators or the subsequent reduction in gambling activity.

In the existing procedure described in the September 2026 notices, SCJ validates reported addresses, Subtel notifies the relevant internet providers, providers implement the blocking instructions, and providers report compliance to the Santiago Court of Appeals with a copy to Subtel. Identification errors and effects on lawful services can be corrected. The Supreme Court's advisory opinion on draft Bill 18.699-07 is separate from this existing enforcement, does not grant operator permission and does not cancel existing blocks.
Process under existing court orders, as described in Subtel's September 2026 notices. The Supreme Court's legislative opinion concerns separate draft provisions.

Two bills address different questions

Our earlier analysis of Chile’s online gambling bill examined the dispute over Bill 14.838-03 and the possible shape of a regulated commercial market. The Senate Economy Committee’s 9 November agenda identifies that initiative separately as the bill regulating online betting platforms.

The Supreme Court’s present report addresses another legislative file.

Separate legislative and enforcement tracks
MeasureMain questionPosition in this story
Bill 18.699-07How website-blocking orders are executedDraft assessed in the Supreme Court’s opinion
Bill 14.838-03The framework for online betting platformsSeparate legislative debate covered previously
Subtel’s September noticesImplementation of existing court decisionsEnforcement already taking place

Keeping these tracks distinct is essential. An opinion about enforcement procedure does not grant operating permission, settle the market-regulation bill or withdraw a particular blocking order.

What this means for operators and internet providers

For internet providers, the practical concern is an instruction they can execute and demonstrate: identified addresses, a clear deadline and a defined route for reporting completion or technical difficulties. Protecting unrelated lawful services also belongs in that process.

For gambling businesses and their commercial partners, the return of a service at a new address is a fragile basis for planning. A working link says little about whether the underlying legal position has changed. Marketing, customer communication and continuity can all depend on decisions made elsewhere in the enforcement chain.

Those are our assessments of the commercial implications. The court’s report itself does not establish how much traffic the September measures removed or forecast the effect of a rewritten bill.

Gamble Ballers view: measure what enforcement achieves

We see the court’s intervention as a useful demand for a better connection between the problem and the remedy. Clear drafting should assign responsibilities to institutions that can carry them out, with a workable way to identify targeted services and correct mistakes.

Repeated domain updates are evidence that enforcement needs maintenance. They do not, by themselves, establish whether blocking succeeds or fails. A useful evaluation would examine the time from identification to implementation, compliance across notified providers, errors and the speed of correction.

For consumer protection, the test extends further: what happens to access, exposure to unlawful services and the ability to obtain redress? A longer blocked-address list captures only one part of that picture.

The next development to watch is how legislators respond to the opinion: whether they revise the scope, change the legislative vehicle or explain what additional mechanism is needed. Chile’s broader market debate continues alongside that task. This report makes the execution question more precise, while leaving the legislative decisions ahead.

Sources and evidence

Supreme Court of Chile, Oficio 314-2026, 12 November 2026; Poder Judicial, 18 November; Judicial Studies Directorate, 20 November; Subtel, 1 and 21 September 2026; TV Senado, Economy Committee agenda for 9 November; Yogonet, 20 November. Earlier Gamble Ballers analysis: 12 November 2026.

Gamble Ballers · News analysis

Topics and categories

Countries
Chile
Regions
Santiago

Background

Earlier reporting in this story.

All coverage: Chile online gambling market access