Home ›News ›PENN’s skill games opportunity depends on where players go

News analysis · Retail casinos & regulation

PENN’s skill games opportunity depends on where players go

The removal of machines gives PENN a chance to attract new and returning visitors. We examine the evidence and the economics behind the opportunity.

In this article
Illustrative photograph of two unbranded switched-off game cabinets in a fictional neighbourhood venue at dusk. Not an actual inspected outlet, enforcement action or PENN casino.
Illustrative editorial image.

PENN Entertainment’s claim that Pennsylvania’s skill games crackdown is bringing customers into its casinos has come under renewed scrutiny. A 16 November Gambling Insider report questioned how much of the reported improvement can be traced to people who previously played machines in shops and bars.

The opportunity is commercially understandable: fewer competing machines could redirect some spending towards licensed operators. The harder questions are where that money goes, which businesses capture it and how much remains after the cost of attracting and serving those customers.

What changed in Pennsylvania

On 15 June, Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court reversed earlier decisions that had placed the disputed skill games outside the reach of the state’s gaming and criminal gambling provisions. It stayed its order for 120 days, recognising businesses’ reliance on the previous legal position. State Police enforcement began on 14 October.

On 10 November, police reported that 12,134 of the 12,202 establishments inspected no longer had skill games, a compliance rate of 99.4%. Investigations continued at other locations. These figures describe inspected premises; they are not a census of every machine or a study of former players’ spending.

For casino operators, this changes the competitive environment. Establishing that competing supply has disappeared is an important first step. Establishing how customers respond requires different evidence.

How the earnings case was built

In a 16 June note, Citizens JMP Securities analysts Jordan Bender and Isabelle Slavin considered a possible 10–15% increase in win per casino machine per day, drawing on experience in Kentucky and Virginia. This is a casino revenue measure. The analysts acknowledged uncertainty about the number of Pennsylvania machines and their earnings, while identifying PENN as the potential largest beneficiary.

Citizens remained encouraged in its 6 November update. Its assessment cited management commentary about early benefits from the shutdown. Separately, SBC Americas reported Jay Snowden’s view that stronger October gaming revenue and additional visitors pointed to customers moving into PENN’s casinos.

The starting point was uneven. Our calculation from Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board figures puts combined September retail slot revenue at PENN’s four Hollywood casinos at US$34.57 million, down 1.68% year on year. Statewide retail slot revenue rose 2.44%. September preceded enforcement and provides a baseline, rather than a measure of its effect.

That comparison also shows why casino performance needs to be examined by property and over time. A stronger subsequent month could reflect several influences, including the previous year’s comparison, promotions and broader demand. Growth needs to be separated into its contributing parts before assigning it to the crackdown.

GambleBallers’ calculation from PGCB retail slot figures puts combined September 2026 revenue at PENN’s four Hollywood casinos at US$34.57 million, down 1.68% year on year. Statewide retail slot revenue rose 2.44%. Enforcement began on 14 October, after September. October includes days before and after that start date. These figures are a baseline, not an estimated causal impact, a market share, EBITDA, or a forecast of extra earnings.
September 2026 came before enforcement began on 14 October. The retail slot figures provide a starting point; they do not measure the crackdown’s effect or customer migration.

Where the displaced spending could go

A machine in a local shop and a casino visit involve different amounts of time and travel. Some former players may find a nearby casino attractive; others may prefer a digital option or simply spend less on gambling.

Possible outcomes, rather than measured market shares
Customer responseCommercial implication
Visits a PENN casinoPotential extra revenue, subject to acquisition costs and repeat visits.
Chooses another licensed venueThe benefit accrues elsewhere.
Moves to regulated online playDigital providers compete for the spending.
Gambles lessSome previous spending leaves the gambling market.

PENN has digital operations as well as casinos, which gives it another possible route to customers. It still has to compete for their choice. A sector-wide increase in online revenue would not identify PENN’s share of that business.

The conversion from revenue to earnings matters too. Taxes, promotional reinvestment, marketing and the incremental cost of serving visitors affect the benefit retained. The valuable outcome is repeat business that covers those costs, including after introductory incentives end.

Our view: a credible opportunity with an unproven size

We regard PENN as a plausible beneficiary of the change, particularly where a casino is convenient for former skill games customers. We expect the opportunity to vary by location. The removal of competing devices supports a positive business case, but its earnings value remains to be demonstrated.

We would look first for sustained gains in visits and retail slot revenue across the relevant properties, allowing for calendar effects, promotions and wider market trends. Comparisons with less exposed properties would help test whether the improvement is concentrated where machines previously competed most directly. That test also needs reliable records of former outlet locations.

Customer evidence would strengthen that assessment. Anonymised research into previous play habits, combined with repeat-visit and spending patterns, could help identify the source and durability of demand. More loyalty registrations alone would leave important questions about why those people arrived and whether they stay.

The timing also calls for patience. PENN’s third-quarter accounts end on 30 September, before enforcement began. October commentary concerns a later period, but the month mixes days before and after the 14 October start. Subsequent months provide a cleaner window for assessing the change.

Our assessment is that the crackdown has created an opportunity PENN can pursue through its existing footprint. The strongest evidence will be a durable increase in customer activity that produces additional earnings after costs. Until that emerges, the scale of the benefit belongs in scenarios rather than established results.

Sources: Pennsylvania Supreme Court (15 June 2026); State Police (September and November 2026); Citizens JMP Securities (16 June and 6 November 2026); PENN results (5 November 2026); PGCB September data; SBC Americas and Gambling Insider (November 2026).

Topics: Business analysis; Regulation; Retail casinos; Customer demand; Skill games. Country: United States. State: Pennsylvania. Company: PENN Entertainment.

Topics and categories

Countries
United States

All coverage: PENN Pennsylvania skill games and casino demand