Home ›News ›FanDuel Predicts grows, but customer payback remains the test

News analysis · Prediction markets

FanDuel Predicts grows, but customer payback remains the test

Flutter is building an audience for event contracts. The harder task is turning those customer relationships into lasting earnings while competition raises the cost of attention.

In this article
Illustrative photograph of anonymous adult supporters entering a fictional American-football stadium through a stainless-steel turnstile in warm afternoon light. Not a real FanDuel venue or photograph of measured customers.
Illustrative editorial image.

Follow-up to our reporting on FanDuel’s US prediction market strategy. Company background: Flutter Entertainment.

FanDuel Predicts is attracting more activity, but its Q3 revenue was immaterial. For Flutter, the opportunity is to build a valuable customer base while the product’s earning potential is still being tested.

In comments reported by Casino.org on 13 November, Flutter chief executive Dan Taylor said new recruits “look a lot like our sportsbook customers”. Chief financial officer Rob Coldrake stressed investment discipline during the discussion with Barclays analyst Brandt Montour. Those remarks put customer economics at the centre of the growth story.

For the group behind Paddy Power, Betfair and Sky Bet, this extends a question raised in our earlier report on FanDuel’s Utah restrictions: how valuable is an early customer relationship if the offering, its availability and the cost of maintaining it can change?

The figures behind the growth

Flutter’s Q3 results, released on 4 November, provide the clearest numerical baseline:

FanDuel Predicts: the disclosed activity measures
FanDuel Predicts measureReported result
Q3 average monthly players66,000; up 39% from Q2
Q3 trading volume$119m; up 102% from Q2
October volume against JulyUp 271%
Q3 revenueNot material

These are different measures. Average monthly players are an activity measure, while trading volume records transactions rather than money earned by Flutter. A larger volume figure can coexist with little revenue if pricing and incentives leave the operator retaining only a small amount.

July to October also spans the start of the NFL season. That comparison captures a different sporting calendar as well as product changes. It cannot isolate how much growth came from better technology, promotion or the seasonal return of American football.

A wider offer inside one app

FanDuel Predicts launched with CME Group in December 2025. Flutter’s latest quarterly filing records a June 2026 expansion through Crypto.com’s regulated exchange and clearinghouse. This gave the product additional sports, entertainment and combination contracts.

By the NFL season, Flutter had launched One App and moved all sports contracts to Crypto.com. Its November presentation described broader markets, improved liquidity and changes to trading fees and contract sizes. Further combination-building features were planned for the fourth quarter.

The commercial logic is straightforward: a broader offer and easier navigation could give customers more reasons to return. Bringing products together may also reduce the effort needed to introduce another service. Neither benefit, on its own, establishes that customers will stay when introductory incentives end.

A cheaper acquisition still needs to earn its keep

Taylor’s shareholder letter says Predicts recruits resemble sportsbook customers but cost less to acquire. It describes building a database in states without FanDuel sportsbooks as a priority.

That comparison is encouraging, but acquisition cost is only the first part of the calculation. The business also needs to know what each group of recruits earns after incentives and servicing costs, how many remain active and how long it takes to recover the initial outlay. Cheaper recruits can still be poor customers economically if they leave quickly.

There is a second uncertainty in the database strategy. Someone who resembles a sportsbook customer is not necessarily a new customer for the group, or someone who will later switch products. The value of early access depends on a lasting relationship and on what Flutter is allowed to offer in that state.

Coldrake acknowledged that Predicts remained small beside rival event-contract operators. Taylor also pointed to difficult economics around promotions. Their comments support a selective approach to spending rather than a race to buy the largest possible headline volume.

Customer payback needs acquisition outlay, retention after introductory incentives and net revenue after costs. Separate full-year 2026 market-making forecasts are $50m revenue and $40m adjusted EBITDA. These trading-business forecasts are not customer-app results and do not establish customer profitability.
Customer payback and market-making forecasts have different reporting scope.

Market-making is a separate source of earnings

Flutter’s presentation set out another opportunity: market-making. It said that activity remained on track for $50m of revenue and $40m of adjusted EBITDA in 2026. These are forecasts for the trading business, not reported revenue or profit from customers using the Predicts app.

Market-making means supplying prices and liquidity for other traders. It draws on a different capability from persuading people to download an app. A successful trading operation could help fund customer acquisition, but it does not demonstrate that the customers acquired are themselves profitable.

Flutter’s guidance allows for an approximately $200m prediction-market adjusted EBITDA loss in 2026. It also expects investment to continue at similar or higher levels in 2027.

The distinction matters when assessing progress. Trading returns, customer revenue and acquisition spending need to be understood within their respective reporting scope. Combining attractive figures from different activities can give an impression of payback that the app’s customer economics have yet to establish.

What would demonstrate lasting value

Flutter’s quarterly filing identifies a cost beyond its own prediction product: heavy advertising by prediction-market operators is beginning to affect sportsbook customer acquisition costs. The company says the impact on existing customers’ betting activity remains limited.

This creates two demands on the same marketing budget: building a position in event contracts and defending the established sportsbook. A useful next disclosure would show retention and net revenue from successive groups of Predicts recruits, together with the time needed to recover their acquisition cost.

The wider US business has little room for wasted spending. Its Q3 adjusted EBITDA, a non-GAAP earnings measure, fell to $3m from $51m a year earlier. The filing attributes margin pressure to several factors, including promotions, payment costs and investment in Predicts, Alberta and the World Cup.

Our reading is that Predicts now has a more credible route to an audience. The next test is whether that audience keeps generating income after the initial promotion. Rising activity earns the product attention; sustained customer payback would earn Flutter a stronger case for continued investment.

Companies and brands: Flutter Entertainment · FanDuel · Crypto.com · CME Group · Barclays
People: Dan Taylor · Rob Coldrake · Brandt Montour
Country: United States · Topics: Prediction markets · Investment & expansion · Financial results · Technology

Topics and categories

Countries
United States

Background

Earlier reporting on this subject.

All coverage: Flutter / FanDuel US prediction market strategy